|
| | | Mickey Mouse
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 11/14/2008 9:25:53 AM
Posts: 587, Visits: 1,167 |
| | Well, I've heard only a couple of those songs last night before (Memories, You Must Love Me, Music of the Night and Jesus Christ Superstar). I think Jason and Brooke should be considered in the bottom, especially Brooke starting over again (this is the second time she did this). David Cook was very good as was Syeshya (and she came across as a performer, and I agree with Simon, a very sexy one at that!!). For me, David Cook again stole the show, by showing his emotion. Basically that leaves the third spot for Carly and David A. Truthfully, I enjoyed Carly's song better than David's, and I would like to see David A there (just to shake him up a little bit), but my gut says it will be Carly as the third. Of Carly, Brooke, and Jason, I would think that Brooke will go home tonight. |
| |
| | | 
Sorcerer Mickey
Group: Forum Moderators
Last Login: Today @ 2:34:18 PM
Posts: 3,368, Visits: 5,274 |
| | my dvr didn't work, my hubby recorded a bunch of deadliest catch and we didn't have space. So what was the theme this week?
Kristi |
| |
| | | 
Sorcerer Mickey
Group: Forum Moderators
Last Login: Yesterday @ 10:31:43 PM
Posts: 2,803, Visits: 3,275 |
| Crap, I can't remember the name of the composer for the week, and I just watched it. It was the guy that wrote/composed Cats, Jesus Christ Superstar, Phantom of the Opera.......
I really, really liked Syesha, for the first time. David C, again loved him. I felt bad for Brooke but it's getting down to the best of the best so I understand if she goes. My bottom 3 would have to be Brooke, Jason, and either Syesha or David A.
Much to my surprise it's bottom 2 and it was Carly and Syesha with Syesha being safe. I guess this goes along with Leanne's theory of a non-American winning the contest. So far I don't believe either one of the David's have been in the bottom 3 (and now 2).
I'm really surprised at the results and have to agree with the judges about it being a huge popularity contest. I'm still not voting though.
I saw in the paper the other day about the ratings for American Idol dropping, I think people are starting to get bored with the show.
Jake and I hangin' with the Big Cheese, Disneyland April '06
 |
| |
| | | Mickey Mouse
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 11/14/2008 9:25:53 AM
Posts: 587, Visits: 1,167 |
| Andrew Llyod Webber was the composer.
I was a little shocked at the outcome. I didn't think Carly would win, but I thought she was good the other night. Brooke definately deserved to go, and Jason wasn't that good, so I feel that both Carly and Syeshya were better.
I heard that too Danette that the ratings have been down this year for IDOL. |
| |
| | |
Sorcerer Mickey
Group: Forum Moderators
Last Login: Today @ 2:34:18 PM
Posts: 3,368, Visits: 5,274 |
| Hmm, first Michael , then Carly. Both non Americans hmm that is interesting. Or maybe it's just a coincendence.
Kristi |
| |
| | | 
Sorcerer Mickey
Group: Administrators
Last Login: 11/17/2008 5:38:21 PM
Posts: 10,885, Visits: 6,229 |
| | I don't think it is coincidence at all. This is AMERICAN idol - not Irish idol. I watched the show and the results last night and was half asleep. But am not surprised Carly went home. Next week - Neal Diamond - they get to murder some of my favorite songs  Leanne
 
May All Your Days Be Filled With Magic! And your nights full of Disney Dreams! |
| |
| | | Mickey Mouse
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 11/14/2008 9:25:53 AM
Posts: 587, Visits: 1,167 |
| | I thought Carly would go home, but not last week. I really feel she was better in that performance than Brooke was in hers and Jason in his. But that goes to show, it sometimes becomes a popularity contest. But in the end, Carly probably wasn't going to make it much further, so it really doesn't matter! |
| |
| | |
Sorcerer Mickey
Group: Administrators
Last Login: 11/17/2008 5:38:21 PM
Posts: 10,885, Visits: 6,229 |
| | This email is from Brooke - my friend Di sent it to me as her friend knows the family, anyway, thought you would all enjoy it! hello to all you amazing people...
>
> Well... Tuesday night was strange, turns out I
> totally forgot the words and actually asked if I
could
> start over... hmmm, I seriously have no earthly idea
> what happened and why it happened, I both laughed
and
> cried when I walked off the stage....a manic moment!
> Live television is a trip... Let me tell ya! I
adored
> the song and committed my whole heart to it, and
> absolutely loved working with Lord Andrew Loyd
Webber,
> what a brilliant and lovely man he is. Very kind...
>
> I want you all to know, after what happened on
> Tuesday, I was certain it was my time to go... I
woke
> up early Wednesday morning and packed up everything
> and prepared to go back into the "real world"... I
> tried to make peace with it, tortured about the
> starting over incident, yet knowing I did everything
I
> possibly could, ... and realizing that making the
Top
> 6 isn't so bad Knowing that Carly and Syesha gave
> such stellar performances, I felt mine paled in
> comparison. And as far as these boys, they're not
> going anywhere. Well... this is a crazy show and
> anything could happen, and it did... ALL BECAUSE OF
> YOU! A GIGUNDO (ji-goon-do) THANKS TO YOU ALL.... I
AM
> STILL HERE!!!! WHAT?!?!?
>
> WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! People, you took me to the TOP
5
> and I am INCREDIBLY stunned and grateful, and
> overwhelmed to be here yet another week, very
surreal.
> Carly is such an amazing vocalist, and a great girl,
I
> will miss her, she is wonderful. I've heard through
> the grapevine that there was voting by the masses,
> voting until fingers were falling off, seriously
this
> thing is so beyond me, Really this is such a group
> effort in a big way, I promise you, that even though
> it doesn't always turn out the best, when I'm up on
> that stage I always give it my best... those judges
> will say what they will, then it is COMPLETELY out
of
> my hands, and in yours, and I just want you all to
> realize, in all seriousness, we're all in this
> together! It is a collaborative effort! I thank you,
> truly and sincerely, I want you to feel of my
> gratitude. When I started this whole thing, waiting
> in line in Philadelphia for 20 hours to audition, I
> thought it was a long shot to even get through the
> first round, I'm absolutely floored that I made it
to
> the TOP 5...
>
> Now it's on to Neil Diamond, were singing two songs
> this week, I thought our schedule was crazy before,
> its about to get impossible, the pressure is
> definitely on, but I am super grateful and looking
> forward to having some FUN with these songs! Y'all
are
> amazing, and I am so glad you all could be a part of
> making this happen...
>
> Love,
> Brooke
May All Your Days Be Filled With Magic! And your nights full of Disney Dreams! |
| |
| | |
Sorcerer Mickey
Group: Forum Moderators
Last Login: Today @ 2:34:18 PM
Posts: 3,368, Visits: 5,274 |
| How neat, well I again missed it. The dvr didn't record idol but it managed to record Deadliest Catch at the same time. HMMM,,,, something tells me that my husband did this on purpose.
Kristi |
| |
|
|